Sunday, February 17, 2008

An embarrassment of riches

Our television is dying what seems to be a slow and painful death. A couple of weeks ago, it started taking longer to turn on in the morning. As the TV-plague progresses, it causes the picture to blink on and off an increasing number of times before it becomes watchable. Sometimes it just won't turn on at all, and we have to turn in it off and try again later. It is a most irritating malady.

So we've begun the search for a new television. Mr. Deplume and I have looked at HDTVs, regular TVs, LCDs and anything in between. Our options are this: buy a regular old tube TV, for a couple of hundred bucks, an HD tube TV for a couple hundred more than that, or a fancy flat screen for yet another few hundred. We've ruled out the HD tube tv, because it is so heavy that we'd need to buy a new stand for it, taking away any savings over the fancy one. So we have to decide on a plain old television that shows the shows, or a fancy one that shows the shows, only much better.

We've always maintained that HDTV is a silly concept, and that the glory of high-definition is just lost on us. But we find outselves drawn to the bright shiny flat screen gorgeousness. But here's the rub: we're cheap. We are really very frugal, and do our best to avoid the consumerism that runs so rampant in our society.

So we're faced with this horrible moral dilemma: do we spend $450 more on a fancy HD television, when a regular old tv will do? If I have that $450 and am willing to part with it, why is it okay not to do some good in the world with it? The food pantry could buy lots of groceries with that. The church could heat the building or pay for programs with that. That money, given to Heifer International could buy sheep or llamas or a cow for a family in a poverty-stricken country.

But I really want the fancy TV.

In thinking and praying on this today (yes, I'm praying about a TV-- wanna make something of it?!?), I'm beginning that I need to give away something to help someone else before I can splurge on a silly want of my own. I'm so grateful to have enough money in the bank that these things are even a possibility. It wasn't all that long ago that we were trying to figure out how to pay the gas bill and also clothe our growing baby girl.

Will Norm's family get the fancy HDTV? Will she learn to get over it and enjoy her current station in life? Will she ever finish the sweater she's working on? These questions and more will be answered in the coming weeks.

10 comments:

  1. we had the exact same thing about a year ago. I have to say our new tv is really nice. I managed to not have purchased a tv for 30 years, until that one.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Down with needless consumerism! I vote for the regular ole T.V. Besides, think of all the brewing I could go with that extra cash. Oh yeah, and give to the poor and stuff.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Isn't it nice to have the choice? We watch a $5 rummage-sale TV that gives everything a nice hint of green, but it's nice to know we don't *have* to.

    ReplyDelete
  4. i was so sure your post was going to be all about how your tv was slowing going out and you were beginning to find yourself grateful for the fact that you'd soon not have one at all--and what a paradigm shifting experience this would be, allowing you to see beyond the veil, at the infinite possibilities that had heretofore been closed to you as you watched and zapped and flipped and tivo'd.

    imagine my horror!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'm so glad I'm not the only one that overanalyzes large purchases. LOL

    ReplyDelete
  6. Football games in HD ROCK! ;)

    ReplyDelete
  7. I can feel your pain. My mom is sending hubby the money to buy himself a nice HDTV because she thinks he NEEDS it. Now, I do appreciate it and will enjoy it because it will take up much less space ..... but at the same time I think our regular ole 5 year old tv works just fine.

    Good luck with your decision!

    ReplyDelete
  8. There's really no show on tv worth paying the price to see it better. I say go with the cheapie and sock the money away for a college fund. :o)

    ReplyDelete
  9. As much as Susan is right, if you stalk the sales on circuit city or best buy's websites, you may get a great deal on what you want. We did - and my conscience was greatly eased. Good Luck!

    ReplyDelete
  10. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete